Although Kelly Clarkson and John Legend, judges on *The Voice*, usually prioritize singing quality over politics, a recent incident sparked controversy.
During competitor Gyth Rigdon’s performance of “God Bless the USA,” Clarkson and Legend faced backlash after criticizing the song selection.
Fans on Twitter reacted strongly, feeling that while the judges’ comments on Rigdon’s performance were valid, they questioned the appropriateness of the song in the current political climate.
The judges found it challenging to critique Rigdon without appearing unpatriotic due to the song’s patriotic nature. Clarkson recognized the sensitivity required in evaluating such a performance and even made light of the difficulty. While they acknowledged Rigdon’s emotional connection to the song, they were honest about his vocal performance.
However, many viewers felt their criticisms were too harsh or unwarranted. This situation highlights the delicate balance judges must maintain between offering constructive feedback and respecting the emotional significance of a performer’s song choice.
Ultimately, it underscores the diversity of audience opinions and the subjective nature of art.
Here is the video:
